Article Side

Online Article Directory!

Hello Guest! Login or Register to submit articles!

The Problem with Peer Review

By Donna Summer Subscribe to RSS | January 21st 2012 | Views:
loading
 
  



The accepted route for the dissemination of analysis findings is thru their publication in peer-reviewed analysis articles. this can be a superb system in several regards - alternative researchers within the field are given a chance to assess whether or not the strategies used were applicable, the experiments well-controlled, the interpretation of the results per the info, which the study very adds to this understanding.

But for all its blessings, pre-publication peer-review doesn't tell us one easy thing: will the experiments be replicated? All too typically, researchers from alternative labs have difficulties replicating revealed findings. Usually, this can be owing to refined variations within the methodology used between labs. Less frequently, the revealed information could have arisen from an honest mistake; a malfunctioning piece of apparatus say, or a forgotten step throughout the statistical analysis. Sadly, there's a 3rd risk, that despite its rarity, gets all the attention: the spectre of fraud.

Peer-review isn't a safe-guard against fraud, as exemplified by the appalling case of Diederik Stapel. Currently, one's scientific productivity is gauged by publication output, and as such, there's huge pressure to publish work in fine quality journals. One unfortunate consequence of this can be that researchers (and editors) are reluctant to retract revealed work when errors (innocent or otherwise) return to light-weight. The competitive ethos of 'publish or perish', combined with the absence of adequate checks and balances, has allowed the foremost corrupt and eager to commit fraudulent acts.

There are alternative issues with this system. Currently, it is many years between a completely unique discovery and its eventual publication, and therefore the vast size of the literature defeats makes an attempt to stay abreast of developments in divergent fields. worry of being 'scooped' causes several scientists to become secretive regarding findings, impeding progress.

I propose a radical solution: the whole abolition of analysis papers.

The nature of publication is counter to the terribly concept of science as a method and not a product. an alternate approach may entail the submission of all novel analysis findings to on-line databases, with credit being given to the first contributors - given that alternative establishments are ready to replicate the results. Hence, it might be in everyone's interest to supply detailed methodology, and support alternative researchers in makes an attempt to copy their work. Unless the work is shown to be reproducible, it might wither and die on the wiki-vine.

Clearly, this doesn't apply to any or all fields. Not everybody has access to a particle accelerator of the dimensions of the big Hadron Collider, and lots of techniques are highly specialised. In these cases, the researchers would be expected to demonstrate their findings to colleagues among the sector.

In this method, analysis would become a a lot of collaborative effort, and fledging lab heads would be higher ready to compete with their competent peers. Journals would publish periodic review articles primarily based on confirmed findings within the database, written by researchers among every field.

The advantages of such a system are considerable. information would become an open resource, with authors a lot of willing to gift at conferences. Scientists would be rewarded for his or her continual analysis outcome instead of punctuated papers, raising morale, and information reliability would be assured. Finally, shorter author lists would build individual contributions a lot of clear. we have a tendency to should acknowledge an antiquated system for what it's, and start to implement the mandatory changes.

Donna Summer - About Author:
EntranceCorner.com giving latest information about a Entrance Exam, Admission Alerts, Check Preparation for Entrance Exams - DA IICT 2012 Eligibility Criteria, DA IICT 2012 Faq's, DA IICT 2012 Important Dates and more.

Share on Facebook Tweet It Stumbleupon this post This post is delicious !

Article Source:
http://www.articleside.com/education-articles/the-problem-with-peer-review.htm

Related Education Articles Subscribe to RSS

BITSAT 2012: Application Deadline, Fee, take a look at format
Published by Donna Summer on February 1st 2012 | Education
Application Process: Interested candidates ought to register their names for BITSAT-2012 by applying...
 
Summer Training 2012 Can Be a Turning Point in Your Career
Published by Ashutosh Kaushik on January 14th 2012 | Education
Summer Training has been declared as the compulsory part of engineering curriculum by almost all top...
 
IIT ENTRANCE EXAM 2012 - Prepare for IIT Entrance Through on-line Coaching
Published by Donna Summer on January 16th 2012 | Education
Separate coaching for all subjects: Individual Professors take regular categories at home or in some...
 
IIT JEE 2012 - Strategies to Crack the IITJEE
Published by Donna Summer on January 6th 2012 | Education
Every year an outsized range of aspirants who dream to secure high IT jobs for themselves enrol for ...
 
IIT JEE 2012 Entrance Exam - IIT JEE just for a Pick Few
Published by Donna Summer on January 16th 2012 | Education
IIT JEE is hard; little doubt regarding it, however not non-achievable. This goal is achieved with e...
 
AIEEE 2012 - AIEEE Preparation through Best Online Coaching
Published by Donna Summer on January 9th 2012 | Education
AIEEE is All India Engineering entrance Examination. Most students ask one or the opposite suggests ...
 
Scoring the Target by Gathering Detailed Information About NDA 2012
Published by Preeti on December 21st 2011 | Education
Entrance exams are the order of the day nowadays with almost every kind of job recruitment and colle...
 
Icing on the Cake for GMAT Test takers after 5th June 2012
Published by Leesa Rey on May 24th 2012 | Education
5th June 2012 will be a historic day for Graduate Management Admission Test (GMAT). From this day on...
 
AIEEE 2012 - Firm Base will cause you to stand at AIEEE 2012 higher
Published by Donna Summer on January 18th 2012 | Education
A firm base is additionally essential as there are numerous candidates who seem for the AIEEE exams ...
 
Entrance Exam Syllabus 2012 - IIT JEE & AIEEE Book Reviews
Published by Donna Summer on January 17th 2012 | Education
This book can evaluate one's strengths and weaknesses. a decent book to travel through to convey the...
 
Entrance Exam 2012 - Cracking Access Exams
Published by Donna Summer on January 12th 2012 | Education
Are access exams such a nightmare? I don't anticipate they are. Access exams are a agency by which t...
 
AIEEE 2012 - Advantages of on-line Coaching for AIEEE Preparation
Published by Donna Summer on January 14th 2012 | Education
AIEEE stands for All India Engineering entrance exam. Varied engineering faculties conduct this comb...
 
AIEEE 2012 Entrance Exam - BE SMART, Select Sensible
Published by Donna Summer on January 18th 2012 | Education
The race is on...and everyone is keen to realize their target and also the target is to crack AIEEE....
 
Entrance Exams 2012 - Gearing Up for GATE Exam and AIEEE Exam Has Become the Foremost Priority for Aspiring Students
Published by Donna Summer on January 13th 2012 | Education
Every year thousands of scholars seem for CBSE board exams. they need a really hectic schedule and s...
 
CAT Exam 2012 Call a Success Call for Management Students
Published by Ankitaroy25 on November 30th 2011 | Education
The CAT is a computer based exam that tests the examinees in quantitative ability, data interpretati...
 
IIT JEE 2012 - IIT Access Assay Dream Appear True
Published by Donna Summer on January 12th 2012 | Education
It is a able-bodied accepted actuality that alone bisected the acceptance advancing for IIT JEE allo...
 
Entrance Exam 2012 - Online Coaching Vs ancient Coaching
Published by Donna Summer on January 17th 2012 | Education
When we have a tendency to say on-line coaching; we mean tutoring the scholar through Well-known edu...
 
Entrance Exams 2012 - Common Entrance Exams provides a sensible Base for college kids Seeking Admissions to Technology Courses
Published by Donna Summer on January 14th 2012 | Education
Those who have passed the science exams are currently ready to secure for themselves the seats in se...
 
IIT JEE 2012 Syllabus - Online Coaching Makes a Successful Future for college students
Published by Donna Summer on January 17th 2012 | Education
Success lies within the hands of the scholar. IIT JEE preparation desires totally different kind of ...
 
Exam 2012 - the Benefits of on-line Testing for Recruiters
Published by Donna Summer on January 16th 2012 | Education
Recruiting the proper candidate for a grip may be a difficult method. Fortunately, you'll be able to...